Communication between South Asian patients and GPs: comparative study using the Roter Interactional Analysis System
British South Asian
South Asian population
A990 Medicine and Dentistry not elsewhere classified
MetadataShow full item record
AbstractBackground The UK South Asian population has poorer health outcomes. Little is known about their process of care in general practice, or in particular the process of communication with GPs. Go to: Aim To compare the ways in which white and South Asian patients communicate with white GPs. Go to: Design of study Observational study of video-recorded consultations using the Roter Interactional Analysis System (RIAS). Go to: Setting West Yorkshire, UK. Go to: Method One hundred and eighty–three consultations with 11 GPs in West Yorkshire, UK were video-recorded and analysed. Go to: Results Main outcome measures were consultation length, verbal domination, 16 individual abridged RIAS categories, and three composite RIAS categories; with comparisons between white patients, South Asian patients fluent in English and South Asian patients non-fluent in English. South Asians fluent in English had the shortest consultations and South Asians non-fluent in English the longest consultations (one-way ANOVA F = 7.173, P = 0.001). There were no significant differences in verbal domination scores between the three groups. White patients had more affective (emotional) consultations than South Asian patients, and played a more active role in their consultations, as did their GPs. GPs spent less time giving information to South Asian patients who were not fluent in English and more time asking questions. GPs spent less time giving information to South Asian patients fluent in English compared with white patients. Go to: Conclusions These findings were expected between patients fluent and non-fluent in English but do demonstrate their nature. The differences between white patients and South Asian patients fluent in English warrant further explanation. How much of this was due to systematic differences in behaviour by the GPs, or was in response to patients' differing needs and expectations is unknown. These differences may contribute to differences in health outcomes.
CitationNeal R, Ali N, Atkin K, Allgar V L, Ali S, Coleman T (2006) 'Communication between South Asian patients and GPs: comparative study using the Roter Interactional Analysis System', British Journal of General Practice, 56 (532), pp.869-875.
PublisherRoyal College of General Practitioners
PubMed Central IDPMC1927096
- A profile of communication in primary care physician telephone consultations: application of the Roter Interaction Analysis System.
- Authors: Innes M, Skelton J, Greenfield S
- Issue date: 2006 May
- South Asian participation in clinical trials: the views of lay people and health professionals.
- Authors: Hussain-Gambles M, Atkin K, Leese B
- Issue date: 2006 Jul
- Frequency and effects of non-English consultations in New Zealand general practice.
- Authors: Wearn A, Goodyear-Smith F, Everts H, Huggard P
- Issue date: 2007 Oct 26
- GPs' experience of managing chronic pain in a South Asian community--a qualitative study of the consultation process.
- Authors: Patel S, Peacock S, McKinley R, Carter DC, Watson PJ
- Issue date: 2008 Apr
- Does burnout among doctors affect their involvement in patients' mental health problems? A study of videotaped consultations.
- Authors: Zantinge EM, Verhaak PF, de Bakker DH, van der Meer K, Bensing JM
- Issue date: 2009 Aug 26
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Are talking therapies culturally relevant for the British South-Asian community?: a look into the views and experiences of British South-AsiansKhalil, Sidhra Adilia (University of Bedfordshire, 2018-11)The personal experiences of South-Asians who have accessed talking therapy have been widely overlooked in the development of culturally adapted therapies for ethnic minorities in the United Kingdom (Naeem et al., 2015). This research aimed to gain an understanding into the experiences of British South-Asian service users, discovering the views held towards existing mental health services and exploring how their experiences shaped these. Additionally, the experiences of community members and professionals were also explored, with all three groups being sought to discover whether talking therapies were culturally relevant for the British South Asian community in England. This qualitative study consisted of 20 semi-structured interviews carried out with British South-Asian service users (n=4), British South-Asian community members (n=5) and mental health professionals (n=11) who had experience of providing therapy to the South-Asian community. Interviews were analysed using inductive thematic analysis, with four key themes arising within each group. There was consensus among the three groups that specific barriers caused difficulty when accessing services, including cultural norms and perceptions towards mental health, English as a second language and limited cultural understanding within existing services. Findings are discussed in relation to previous research into minority communities and recommendations for future research are made.
Promoting organ donation and transplantation among South Asians in the United Kingdom: the role of social networks in the South Asian communityRandhawa, Gurch; University of Luton (North American Transplant Coordinators Organization, 2005-09)The percentage of South Asians on the kidney transplant waiting list in the United Kingdom is 3 times their percentage in the general population. Obviously, organ donation and transplantation among South Asians in the United Kingdom needs improvement. In recent years, ethnically targeted campaigns in the mass media have specifically attempted to attract donors from the South Asian communities. A number of pilot studies have been done to evaluate the effectiveness of these initiatives in providing information about organ donation to South Asians. Results indicate that detailed information related to transplantation was learned mainly by people within the community receiving transplants and was transmitted through various informal community networks rather than through the resources provided by the Department of Health. This article provides an overview of who South Asians are and how these community networks were established. Transplant professionals must devise effective strategies to access these community networks, thereby raising the consciousness of transplantation among South Asians in the United Kingdom.
An examination of concordance and cultural competency in the diabetes care pathway: South Asians living in the United KingdomRandhawa, Gurch; Wilkinson, Emma; University of Bedfordshire (Medknow Publications, 2012)The Care Pathway project used a multilevel and multimethod approach to explore access to the care pathway for diabetic renal disease. Taking what was known about the outcomes of ethnic minority patients with diabetic renal disease; the study sought to explore and further understand how and why South Asian patients’ experiences may be different from the majority of population in relation to access. Through improved understanding of any observed inequalities, the study aimed to inform the development of culturally competent diabetes services. The design incorporated audits of patient indicators for diabetes and renal health at key points in the pathway: Diagnosis of diabetes and referral to specialist renal services in two years- 2004 and 2007, and qualitative individual interviews with patients and providers identified through the 2007 samples. This article describes the care provider perspective of access to diabetes care from a thematic analysis of 14 semistructured interviews conducted with professionals, at three study sites, with different roles in the diabetes pathway. National policy level initiatives to improve quality have been mirrored by quality improvements at the local practice level. These achievements, however, have been unable to address all aspects of care that service providers identified as important in facilitating access to all patient groups. Concordance emerged as a key process in improving access to care within the pathway system, and barriers to this exist at different levels and are greater for South Asian patients compared to White patients. A conceptual model of concordance as a process through which access to quality diabetes care is achieved and its relation to cultural competency is put forward. The effort required to achieve access and concordance among South Asian patients is inversely related to cultural competency at policy and practice levels. These processes are underpinned by communication.