Learning to teach English in Hong Kong: effects of the changeover in sovereignty
SubjectsX162 Teaching English as a Foreign Language (TEFL)
English as a Second Language
English as an Additional Language
MetadataShow full item record
AbstractTeachers undergo changes in their beliefs, knowledge and practices on an individual level as they learn how to teach. If society undergoes significant change, as Hong Kong did during the transition from British to Chinese rule in 1997, then social groups within society such as teachers are likely to react to change in different and complex ways. The purpose of this investigation is to exam.ine the changes experienced by teachers of English in Hong Kong, with a focus on teachers who received their teacher preparation at one Hong Kong institution during the final years leading up to the transition. The educational, linguistic, social and political context of Hong Kong is first described through a study of the research literature and a number of theories and models of change are presented through which the findings of the investigation are analysed. The main sources of data for the investigation consist of questionnaire responses, interview transcriptions and lesson observation reports of trainee English teachers during and after graduation from a BA course in TESL at a Hong Kong university. The main conclusions of the investigation are: (i) Educational issues and particularly those affecting ELT became more high-profile and politicised in the lead up to and after the changeover. (ii) English teachers in Hong Kong experience conflict between their desired approaches and the realities and constraints of the Hong Kong teaching context. These constraints provide a common justification for lack of innovative behaviour and make it possible for teachers to put off being innovative in the classroom indefinitely. (iii) At the same time, English teachers in Hong Kong are becoming more empowered within the educational system in reaction to challenges to their competency and as they have realised that they can affect educational policy through individual and collective action. The findings suggest that colonial discourses as documented by Pennycook (1998) of English language teaching still persist in Hong Kong, as they have been shown to do in other post-colonial societies, and Hong Kong is undergoing a post-handover period of change as it struggles to synthesise the educational legacies of the colonial period with new initiatives adopted to address Hong Kong's changing educational and social needs. The results of the research are developed into an original model of the factors impacting English language education in Hong Kong. The generic model is then elaborated in two versions, one of which applies before the changeover and the other after it.
CitationUrmston, A. (2003) 'Learning to teach English in Hong Kong: effects of the changeover in sovereignty'. PhD thesis. University of Luton.
PublisherUniversity of Bedfordshire
TypeThesis or dissertation
DescriptionA thesis submitted to the University of Luton, in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy
The following license files are associated with this item:
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
An investigation of explicit strategy instruction on EFL reading of undergraduate English majors in ThailandKhaokaew, Burana (University of BedfordshireUniversity of Bedfordshire, 2012-08)As academic and professional knowledge is available around the world through publications in English, the ability to read in English is now widely seen as an essential basic skill for university graduates in countries, like Thailand, where English is a foreign language. However, students often fail to reach a level of reading ability that allows them to read these publications with confidence. It is important that instruction in Reading skills should be improved. It has been claimed that instruction in the use of reading strategies is helpful in improving the reading skills of EFL learners. Research has suggested that explicit instruction can be particularly valuable. This thesis investigates the reading strategies used by Thai university students and investigates whether a short course based on explicit reading strategy instruction can be effective in encouraging the use of strategies and improving reading skills for Thai university students. Based on a literature review on Reading strategy instruction, a framework was developed and applied in the adaptation of a set of materials for use in providing English major Thai university students with explicit instruction in the use of reading strategies. The following research questions were investigated: What are the reading strategies that Thai undergraduate English major students employ in the EFL reading process? Does reading strategy instruction affect students’ use of reading strategies in English? How much improvement do the students show on measures of reading performance after receiving a programme of reading strategy instruction? In a quasi-experimental research design, one class of fifteen students, the Experimental group, was given a twelve-week course in Reading that included explicit instruction in reading strategies while a second group of thirteen students (matched for background characteristics), the Control group, was given a parallel course that did not include explicit strategy instruction. Both quantitative and qualitative comparisons were made. Students were given reading tests and responded to questionnaires about their use of strategies at the beginning and end of their courses. They were also interviewed and performed think-aloud verbal protocols in which they reported in their use of reading strategies as they carried out reading tasks. Participants in the Experimental group reported using a wider range of strategies than those in the Control group following instruction and generally made greater improvements in their reading test scores. The findings support the value of explicit instruction in reading strategies for Thai university students. However, concerns remain about Thai students reliance on translation and slow, careful reading even following instruction in more strategic approaches.
Validating a set of Japanese EFL proficiency tests: demonstrating locally designed tests meet international standardsDunlea, Jamie (University of BedfordshireUniversity of Bedfordshire, 2015-12)This study applied the latest developments in language testing validation theory to derive a core body of evidence that can contribute to the validation of a large-scale, high-stakes English as a Foreign Language (EFL) testing program in Japan. The testing program consists of a set of seven level-specific tests targeting different levels of proficiency. This core aspect of the program was selected as the main focus of this study. The socio-cognitive model of language test development and validation provided a coherent framework for the collection, analysis and interpretation of evidence. Three research questions targeted core elements of a validity argument identified in the literature on the socio-cognitive model. RQ 1 investigated the criterial contextual and cognitive features of tasks at different levels of proficiency, Expert judgment and automated analysis tools were used to analyze a large bank of items administered in operational tests across multiple years. RQ 2 addressed empirical item difficulty across the seven levels of proficiency. An innovative approach to vertical scaling was used to place previously administered items from all levels onto a single Rasch-based difficulty scale. RQ 3 used multiple standard-setting methods to investigate whether the seven levels could be meaningfully related to an external proficiency framework. In addition, the study identified three subsidiary goals: firstly, toevaluate the efficacy of applying international standards of best practice to a local context: secondly, to critically evaluate the model of validation; and thirdly, to generate insights directly applicable to operational quality assurance. The study provides evidence across all three research questions to support the claim that the seven levels in the program are distinct. At the same time, the results provide insights into how to strengthen explicit task specification to improve consistency across levels. This study is the largest application of the socio-cognitive model in terms of the amount of operational data analyzed, and thus makes a significant contribution to the ongoing study of validity theory in the context of language testing. While the study demonstrates the efficacy of the socio-cognitive model selected to drive the research design, it also provides recommendations for further refining the model, with implications for the theory and practice of language testing validation.
Evaluation of the English for Specific Purposes (ESP) programme in engineering universities in Punjab, PakistanAnwar, Rana Muhammad Bilal (University of BedfordshireUniversity of Bedfordshire, 2016-02)The study evaluates aspects of an on-going educational programme “the ESP Programme” in the Engineering Universities of Punjab, Pakistan. It also highlights the importance of English Language program evaluation before and after teaching English language. Program evaluation is a largely ignored area of English language teaching. To date, there has been little research into the evaluation of academic programs in the field of ESP. Pakistan's English for Engineers university programme is a case in point. Although this programme was developed almost two and half decades ago, so far it has not been evaluated systematically in a way which would identify its merits and shortcomings and provide a basis for its continuous, systematic, research informed development. The present study is a report on an attempt to fill this gap in two ways: (a) by considering how a thorough evaluation of an on-going ESP (English for Specific Purposes) programme in engineering universities in Punjab, Pakistan could be carried out in the context of the concern for 'quality assurance' in educational innovation. (b) by developing some research instruments required for carrying out the evaluation The study describes how questionnaires, interviews, observations, and document analysis were designed and used to gather qualitative and quantitative data revealing a positive general attitude toward teaching/learning English as a foreign language .There was general agreement that the broad needs of the students had been well recognised and the objectives had been well set. However, the programme was not regarded a success due to its failure to achieve the intended objectives. The findings of the study also show the importance of all four language skills in an ESP program, both for the students’ academic studies and for their target careers. Generally speaking, the evaluation results indicate that the ESP is helpful to some extent but the programme is unsuccessful on the whole. There is no learners’ 'needs analysis' with respect to their 'wants' and 'wishes'. There is big incongruity between the opinion on priorities by programme designers and policy makers, lack of teacher competence, training, and the neglect of learner assessment and evaluation. The study recommends the provision of teacher training and the recruitment of additional ESP teaching staff as first steps towards the necessary improvements. It is also concluded that the collection of multiple types of data from various sources and places is necessary to overcome many of the problems commonly associated with needs analysis and evaluation studies.